109 Broad St, MIDDLETOWN

Step into a rare piece of Middletown’s history at 109 Broad Street. Built in 1910, this stately three-story Victorian has been lovingly restored over time, blending preserved architectural details with thoughtful modern updates. With over 4,300 square feet of finished living space and soaring first-floor ceilings more than 10 feet high, this home tells the story of more than a century of life in the heart of town—rich with craftsmanship, character, and charm. Original window sashes, transoms, mantels, heart of pine floors, natural wood trim, chestnut accents, pocket doors, double bay windows on two floors, and built-in cabinetry remain beautifully intact—a level of craftsmanship rarely seen in modern construction and a testament to the home’s enduring quality. Inside, you’ll find eight bedrooms and three full baths across three finished levels, plus a spacious 1756 sq ft basement with 7'6" ceilings and a French drain system that keeps the space dry and functional year-round—ideal for storage, a personal gym, hobbies, or future finishing potential. The main level features a full bath and multiple flexible spaces, including the option to create a first-floor primary suite or guest quarters—a rare combination of function and flexibility that the current owners enjoyed and stated was one of their favorite features about the home. The kitchen offers a fresh, modern contrast to the home’s historic bones. Cool modern cabinetry and stainless steel appliances pair with original built-in oak cabinets and beadboard wainscoting, while a center island with breakfast bar provides ample counter space and dining space. This mix of old and new creates a kitchen that feels both timeless and updated. Upstairs, the second level includes five generously sized bedrooms and a full bath—one with its own private porch—while the third level offers three additional bedrooms and a third full bath. This layout is ideal for multigenerational living, large families, or those who need both home and personal office space under one roof. Set on a rare 0.77-acre lot just off Main Street, the grounds are a private in-town oasis. A full wraparound front porch and side porches evoke a slower pace of life, while the fenced backyard is complete with an 8-foot deep gunite swimming pool with a saltwater filter system and a whimsical kids’ clubhouse. A detached two-car garage and parking pad provide ample off-street parking—another rare find for this location. Whether you’re sipping coffee on the porch or hosting summer gatherings by the pool, every inch of this property invites you to slow down and savor the moment. This home once served as part of Middletown’s network of boardinghouses—a reminder of the town’s storied past and welcoming spirit. Lovingly maintained, it’s both a nod to the past and a canvas for future generations. Efficient geothermal HVAC ensures year-round comfort and sustainability, while the walkable location—just steps from parks, schools, shops, restaurants, and trails—offers a lifestyle that blends community, convenience, and charm. All this, just minutes from I-70. Per Middletown town code, the property is eligible for potential subdivision into up to three lots. Buyer must confirm all zoning and development details directly with the Town of Middletown. Homes like this don’t come around often—filled with soul, space, and story—just waiting for the next chapter to begin. It’s the kind of home you don’t just live in—you grow into, make memories in, and pass down with pride. Call today for your private tour! Showings begin May 1st, not before.